Blythe was a student at St. Cuthbert's and a friend of Annabelle. Noticing the rivalry between two other students, Meredith and Mary, they proposes to this last to help her against her nemesis. However, Mary, most frightened by Annabelle (in a manner, similar to Darla into Sunnydale) and her friends, refuses. In returned, Annabelle and her friends harassed her. Suspecting that the three girls murdered Meredith, Mary confronted them into cafeteria, under Faith Lehane and Winifred Burkle (disguised into gym teacher and lunch lady) eye's. Fred find they were vampires. Fearing that Mary tell to Faith that they were the real murderers, they attack Faith. Unsuspecting her Slayer status, Blythe was dusted. She was working for Drusilla.